How do you measure whether your content strategy is working?

The short answer: measure what people choose to do, not what you paid to show them. Count returning viewers, earned views and new subscribers per view, branded search, enquiries set against your upload calendar, and the answers to “where did you hear about us?”. Add one new measure: whether AI tools name you when buyers ask about your category. Read it every month, and give the strategy two years before you judge what it returns.

72%

of the views on big companies’ YouTube uploads looked paid for

0.2%

of brand memory lift explained by engagement rate; creative quality explained 54.6%

0

of about 815 companies’ filings we read put a figure on what YouTube brought in

Why the usual numbers mislead

Total views and engagement rate are easy to count and easy to inflate. In our audit of company YouTube channels, 72% of the views on big companies’ uploads looked paid for. Channels whose views mostly looked paid for had about 0.7 new subscribers per 1,000 views, against 5.0 where views were mostly earned. In one study of paid TikTok ads, engagement rate explained 0.2% of the lift in brand memory; creative quality explained 54.6%.

New subscribers per 1,000 views

Channels whose views are mostly earned 5.0

 

Mixed 2.9

 

Channels whose views mostly look paid for 0.7

 

Casual Films, Company YouTube Benchmark, September 2026: 1,062 channels with 100,000+ lifetime views. Medians; links show no cause.

What should you measure?

MeasureWhat it tells youWhere to find it
Returning viewersWhether people come back by choiceYouTube Studio
Earned views and new subscribers per 1,000 viewsWhether people chose to watchYouTube Studio; compare paid and unpaid
Branded searchWhether more people look for you by nameGoogle Search Console, Google Trends
Enquiries against the upload calendarWhether films go with more leadsYour CRM, by week
“Where did you hear about us?”Which films people rememberA field on every contact and sign-up form
What AI says about youWhether ChatGPT, Perplexity and Gemini name you, and which pages they rely onAsk the same buyer questions every month, several times each
What people rememberWhether the films build memory, not just clicksA short survey, or a pre-test of each idea

How do you measure whether a content strategy is working?

  1. Set the measures before the first upload. The few companies that report a result from YouTube measured it from the start. None of the filings we read, from about 815 companies, put a figure on what YouTube brought in.
  2. Put a next step on every film. In a closer look at 30 company channels, 9 carried a trackable link to a place to act on at least a tenth of their uploads.
  3. Ask where people heard of you. Ahrefs asked new sign-ups; 29,000 said they found it through YouTube.
  4. Track the same buyer questions in AI tools. Run each question several times and report ranges, not single answers. Our AI answer study shows the method.
  5. Read monthly, judge over two years. On UK linear TV, more than two thirds of the profit came after the first 13 weeks. Monthly reads decide what to push; the two-year view decides whether it paid.
  6. Read the films themselves. Before and after release, check each film for attention, memory, emotion and action. Our video assessor gives ranked fixes tied to moments in a film.

For measuring a single film rather than a whole strategy, see How do you measure whether a corporate film worked?

Chart: how much each factor can multiply the return, creative quality 12x, and the share of brand memory lift explained

Likes and engagement say little about memory. From Why it’s worth investing in video.

Questions people ask

What is a good subscriber-per-view rate?

Among company channels with 100,000+ lifetime views, the median was 5.0 new subscribers per 1,000 views where views were mostly earned, and 0.7 where they mostly looked paid for.

How do we measure brand awareness from video?

Branded search, “where did you hear about us?” answers and a short memory survey are the cheapest honest signals. Views alone are not.

How do we know if AI mentions us?

Write 20 or so questions your buyers ask, ask each one several times in each AI tool, and count how often you are named and which pages are cited. Do it monthly.

When should we stop a series?

When a monthly read shows few returning viewers and no next steps after a fair run. Drop it and put the budget behind what works.

Where these figures come from

  • Casual Films, Company YouTube Benchmark, September 2026: 1,492 company channels read through the YouTube API; “looks paid for” means 5,000+ views with likes under 0.1% of views, a signal rather than proof of spend; about 815 companies’ filings read; Casual YouTube Channel Objectives Audit, 29 September 2026 (30 channels). Links show no cause.
  • System1 with WPP Media and TikTok, The Creator Effectiveness Playbook, 2026: 1,217 paid TikTok ads; consumer ads (0.2% and 54.6%).
  • Ahrefs’ own sign-up survey, 2022 (29,000). Thinkbox, Profit Ability 2, 2024: 141 UK brands, mostly consumer (two thirds after 13 weeks).

Read the full papers on our research page.

About Casual. Casual makes business films that change what people do. Since 2006 we have made films for companies such as Google, HSBC, BMW and GSK, from eight offices in seven countries. Want to know what your content is really doing? Brief us and a producer will reply within two working hours.