The short answer: most brand videos fail because they give people no reason to watch. They talk about the company instead of following one person with something at stake. They open on images the viewer has seen a hundred times. And nobody agreed, before filming, what the film had to make people do. The research points the same way: in a study of 1,700 B2B ads, 76.7% scored one star out of five for emotional response, a level that predicts no growth in market share.
This page sets out the five most common reasons, what the evidence says about each, and what to do instead. Every figure names its source at the end.
The five reasons brand videos fail
- There is no one to follow. A film about "the company" asks viewers to care about an abstraction. In Casual's own research on 50 films, 19 of 22 award winners had a protagonist, one person the story follows. Of the 28 films with no award found, 7 did. Awards measure quality. They do not measure business results. Even so, the pattern is hard to ignore.
- There is no feeling. LinkedIn counted more than 13,000 B2B video ads and found that 7 in 100 showed any human emotion. In its own data, brand awareness videos with authentic emotion drew 78% more engagement on LinkedIn.
- The goal was never agreed. A film asked to recruit, sell and explain at once usually does none of them well. If the team can't finish the sentence "After watching, this audience will...", the film isn't ready to brief.
- The opening looks like every other corporate film. The drone shot over head office. The "We are..." voiceover. Rows of executives in front of a brick wall. Viewers recognise these in seconds and file the film as corporate content. The fix is to start inside the moment that matters: a face, an object, an action.
- It is judged on the wrong number. In Casual's audit of more than 1,600 company YouTube channels, 72% of the views on big companies' uploads looked paid for. A big view count can hide a film nobody chose to watch. In a study of paid TikTok ads, engagement rate explained 0.2% of the lift in brand memory, while creative quality explained 54.6%.
Why the creative matters more than the media plan
Across about 7,000 UK campaigns, the best creative returned up to 12 times more than the worst, in accelero's analysis for Thinkbox. Of the factors a marketer controls, creative quality moved the return most. Those campaigns were mostly from consumer brands. B2B evidence points the same way: in the IPA's B2B cases, emotional campaigns reported very large gains on 1.4 business measures per campaign, against 0.2 for rational ones.
How to make a brand video that works
- Agree the action first. Name what the film must make people do, and the number that will show it. Then write the film.
- Find one person and something at stake. To recruit engineers, HSBC cast its own principal engineers as the heroes of an action thriller: one hero film and six character films. Applications per role rose 59% after launch. That is the result of the whole campaign: the films, paid media and a landing page together.
- Open inside the moment. The first seconds decide whether anyone stays. Spend them on the story, before the logo.
- Say something specific. Replace "we believe" with a fact the viewer can check or a scene they can see.
- Make it for where it will be watched. Plan the cuts for each channel before the shoot. On YouTube, teach: in Casual's audit, how-to series beat the rest of their own channel in 12 of 17 tests, and series of whole-event footage did in none of 13.
- Measure what it changes. Track the action you agreed, against a baseline. See how to measure whether a corporate film worked.
Questions people ask
Is a bigger budget the answer?
Usually no. In Casual's research, low-budget award winners had a protagonist nearly as often as expensive ones: 10 of 12, against 9 of 10. A protagonist is a decision made in the script.
How long should a brand video be?
As long as the story can hold people. Heineken's "Open Your World" kept 65% of viewers to the end of a film four and a half minutes long. A weak story loses people in seconds at any length.
Can you tell if a film will work before it launches?
Partly. Testing a cut with the people it is for shows whether they follow the story, remember the point and feel what you intended. You can also run a cut through Improve my video, which gives ranked fixes tied to moments in the film.
Where these figures come from
- 76.7% of 1,700 B2B ads at one star: The B2B Institute at LinkedIn and System1, Cashing in on Creativity, 2021.
- 7 in 100 B2B video ads with human emotion, and +78% engagement: LinkedIn Creative Labs, The Art and Science of Video Storytelling, 2025. LinkedIn's own counts; engagement is not sales.
- Protagonists in 19 of 22 award winners: Casual research, August 2026, 50 films read by Casual's AI film assessor. Not all are B2B.
- 72% of views that look paid for, and series results: Casual Films, Company YouTube Benchmark, September 2026. "Looks paid for" means 5,000 or more views with likes on fewer than 0.1% of them, a signal rather than proof.
- 12 times return from creative: Thinkbox, The drivers of profitability, 2023, from accelero's analysis.
- 0.2% and 54.6% of brand memory lift: System1 with WPP Media and TikTok, The Creator Effectiveness Playbook, 2026 (consumer TikTok ads).
- 1.4 against 0.2: Binet and Field, 5 Principles of Growth in B2B Marketing, The B2B Institute at LinkedIn and the IPA, 2019.
- Heineken: APG, YouTube Works for Brands, 2018.
The papers behind Casual's own figures are on our research page, open to read in full.
About Casual. Casual makes business films that change what people do. Since 2006 we have made films for companies such as Google, HSBC, BMW and GSK, from eight offices in seven countries. Planning a brand film? Brief us and a producer will reply within two working hours.